They Called It a Grant. It Was a Refund.

In September 2024, Florida's biggest Medicaid contractor owed the state $67 million for overbilling. That money belonged to taxpayers. It was a refund, nothing more.

On the way back to the treasury, $10 million of it took a detour. It stopped at a charity attached to the First Lady, got relabeled a "grant," passed through two nonprofits in under three weeks, and landed in a political committee run by the governor's chief of staff, 45 days before an election.

A grand jury looked at all of it and wrote the word "misappropriated." Then it said nobody would be charged. You should understand both halves of that sentence, because the second half is how the system protects itself.

Gmail is free, but you pay with your data. Proton Mail is different.

We don’t scan your messages. We don’t sell your behavior. We don’t follow you across the internet.

Proton Mail gives you full-featured, private email without surveillance or creepy profiling. It’s email that respects your time, your attention, and your boundaries.

Email doesn’t have to cost your privacy.

Ditch the Gmail data grab

Start with what the grand jury found, which is the proven part. Centene overbilled Florida Medicaid, the program that covers poor kids and nursing home patients. The Agency for Health Care Administration negotiated a repayment. Then, in two drafts on consecutive days in mid-September 2024, the settlement was rewritten so that $10 million would go not to the state but to the Hope Florida Foundation.

The grand jury called this money "taxpayer money" and said "it should have been treated as such instead of being allocated for partisan political purposes." The administration's chief-of-staff-to-be, Jason Weida, who signed the deal as AHCA secretary, told the panel the $10 million was a "bonus" on top of what Centene owed. The grand jury rejected that outright.

Here is the tell. Centene got a year to pay the state's $57 million. It got seven days to pay the charity's $10 million. The grand jury wrote: "We believe the rush was due to the impending election which was just 45 days away." When the treasury can wait and the PAC cannot, you already know who the deal was for.

Centene wired the $10 million on October 4, 2024. Hurricane Milton hit Florida days later. According to the presentment, on October 11, while the state was in disaster mode, Uthmeier personally contacted two groups, the Florida Chamber's Secure Florida's Future and Save Our Society from Drugs, about applying for Hope Florida grants.

Each got $5 million. Both applications, the grand jury found, "mischaracterized" what the money was for and promised it would not be used politically. Secure Florida's Future then sent $3.75 million to Keep Florida Clean. Save Our Society from Drugs sent $4.75 million. Distributions were complete by October 22. The charity's own chairman, Joshua Hay, testified the money sat with Hope Florida only "a couple of days."

So follow the shape of it. Ten million dollars in. Ten million dollars out. Eight and a half million into a committee chaired by the governor's chief of staff. Seven million from that committee to the state Republican Party. The charity was a hallway, not a destination.

And the charity itself? The grand jury tried to verify Hope Florida's claimed success stories and was "unable to get any evidence to substantiate" them. Witnesses described the initiative as "just a concept." A concept moved $10 million faster than most Florida families can get a Medicaid claim approved.

Amendment 3 would have legalized recreational marijuana. It needed 60 percent. It got 55.9 percent. The DeSantis operation spent October 2024 campaigning against it, and Keep Florida Clean was the vehicle. The people running the state wanted a war chest, and they had a $67 million refund sitting on a desk with a signature line.

The psychology is simple and familiar. When you have spent years telling yourself the government is you, its money starts to feel like your money. The refund was not stolen in the way a defense lawyer would recognize. It was reassigned, by people who could not imagine a version of the public interest that differed from their own campaign.

I spent twenty years inside campaigns, and I have watched money get renamed on its way to where it was always going. What I never saw was a state's own Medicaid repayment used as the seed capital. That is not fundraising. That is the treasury as a donor.

Now the second half of the grand jury's sentence. "Despite our finding that the money was misappropriated, we find insufficient evidence to charge anyone criminally." Why? Because, in the grand jury's words, "Nobody will take responsibility for deciding the $10 million of taxpayer money would go to Hope Florida." Moody's chief deputy, John Guard, had "reservations," knew the money "belonged to the state of Florida," and signed after Moody authorized it. The Department of Health's chief of staff signed during Hurricane Helene without reading it and testified she would not have if she had known where it would end up.

The governor, the former attorney general who is now a U.S. senator, and the current attorney general who chaired the committee that got the money were not called to testify. All three deny wrongdoing. DeSantis called it a "hoax" and said he is "very happy with how everything was done." Uthmeier called it a "big nothingburger" and noted he has not been indicted. Both statements are true and neither answers the question of who decided.

Then the report was sealed. For seven months the Leon County clerk told journalists there were no responsive records. It took a leak to CBS News Miami's Jim DeFede to put it in front of you. A finding of misappropriation with no defendant and no docket is not accountability. It is a record of the absence of it.

This is the part that should bother you no matter your party. The same week, Arizona's attorney general closed a two-year pay-to-play probe of a Democratic governor with no charges and a plea for the Legislature to fix disclosure rules. Two states, two parties, one conclusion: the conduct was documented and the law had no room for it. The grand jury in Florida asked for the same thing, a rule that every dollar the state receives goes into the general fund, with penalties for anyone who routes it elsewhere.

What is proven: the money trail, the dates, the rewritten settlement, the grand jury's findings. What is alleged: that Uthmeier directed the flow, which is the panel's account and which he disputes. What BTP is arguing: that when a refund owed to the public can be renamed a grant and delivered to a party in 18 days, the name on the check was never the point.

If you live in Florida, ask your state representative one question before the next session: will you vote to require every settlement dollar to go through the general fund?

Burn Notice: A grand jury found that $10 million owed to Florida taxpayers was renamed a grant, handed to a charity for two days, and delivered to a political party, and the only reason no one was charged is that no one would admit to deciding it.

— Michael

90 days free. BTP Insider subscribers get the Friday deep read, the monthly receipts digest, podcast Q&A priority, and the quarterly print bundle. The election room is open — try it free for 90 days, no charge unless you decide to stay. Start your free trial →

Worth your time: We vet every brand and newsletter we recommend. Deals from brands we trust → · Semafor Flagship — the global stories that shape what happens here →