The Confidence of a Mediocre White Man

Eighteen funerals. More than 750 wounded. A strait we no longer control. Diesel at $5.85, the highest number ever printed on an American pump.

And the man who ran it is, according to two people who know him, telling friends he should be president.

God grant me the confidence of a mediocre white man.

ADVERTISEMENT

TLDR AI is the free daily brief curated by Anthropic and ex-Google engineers. The stories, models, and research they'd send a colleague, summarized for 1.1M+ readers.

Subscribe for free

Proven: the war started on February 28 with U.S. and Israeli strikes. We hit first. Congress never voted to authorize it, and the administration's legal position is that a ceasefire in April stopped the 60-day War Powers clock, which experts at Brookings say never stopped running because the blockade and the shooting never stopped.

Reported: NBC News says Hegseth and his wife Jennifer have spent months talking with close associates about a 2028 run, on the theory that his "toughness" and appeal to the MAGA base would carry. Hegseth called the story "100% false" and posted, "My only job: Make @DeptofWar Great Again." Trump's response was "it's very early to talk about that," which is not a no.

Argued, by me: this is the worst exchange rate of any war of choice in American history. Not the deadliest. Vietnam and Iraq buried far more of our people, and I won't cheapen those graves by pretending otherwise. But no Secretary in our history has ever started a war, declared "a capital-V military victory" inside six weeks, and then watched the enemy walk away holding the chokepoint that sets the price of every gallon in your tank.

Go back to March 8. Hegseth sat down with 60 Minutes and said, "This is only just the beginning." He said the gravity bombs "haven't even really begun." He said we were "fightin' to win" and that we "set the terms."

A month later, on April 8, he stood at the Pentagon and called it "a historic and overwhelming victory on the battlefield." He said Epic Fury had "rendered [Iran's military] combat-ineffective for years to come."

PBS ran the claim against the record the next day. Iran's highly enriched uranium was still in Iranian hands. The regime was still standing. And the Strait of Hormuz, which we spent decades keeping open, was now under what the Stimson Center's Kelly Grieco called "unprecedented" Iranian control. Aaron David Miller at Carnegie put it plainly: "If the war stopped tomorrow, this constitutes a historic strategic defeat for the U.S., especially when this was a war of choice."

Then the ceasefire broke. A second one in June broke too. By late July, U.S. jets were flying ten straight nights of strikes, and this weekend we hit three Iranian tankers after the Revolutionary Guard fired ballistic missiles at two of our warships.

That's the "victory." Five months after the parade, we're still trading fire with a country we supposedly finished.

Last week, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick went on CNBC and said no Americans had died in Iran. He had to apologize. He said he'd been thinking of Venezuela.

Trump, asked about the toll, said, "I call it a military conflict because it's small potatoes for us." Vance said he wouldn't "call it a war" at all.

And Hegseth, at a Pentagon briefing on March 4, days after six Army reservists were killed in an Iranian strike on an operations center in Kuwait, complained about the coverage: "When a few drones get through or tragic things happen, it's front-page news. I get it. The press only wants to make the president look bad. But try for once to report the reality."

Read that again. Six reservists came home in boxes that week, and the Secretary of War's grievance was the headline.

I spent twenty years inside campaigns. I have written the talking point that turns a number into a "narrative problem." I know exactly what it does to you to do it, and I'm not proud of the times I did. But I never once saw a principal stand next to a casualty announcement and make himself the victim of it.

Here's the part I can't stop thinking about, and it's the part that isn't about Iran at all.

I have sat in rooms my whole career where a man with a fraction of the record and ten times the certainty got the benefit of every doubt. I had to bring the proof twice. He brought a haircut and a hunch. Nobody asked him whether he'd earned the chair. They asked me whether I was sure I belonged in it.

Pete Hegseth is that man, promoted to the top of the org chart. A weekend TV host who was handed the largest military on earth, started a war without a vote, declared it won, lost the strait, put diesel at a record, and now, per two people who know him, believes the natural next step is the Oval Office.

That isn't ambition. Ambition is earned. That is a man who has never once been told no by anyone with the power to make it stick, and has confused that for merit.

He polls at one percent with his own base. Fifty-six percent of the country wants him out of the job he already has. He isn't a threat to win 2028.

He's a warning about what Republican voters have been trained to accept as a qualification. Loyalty over competence. Volume over record. A "capital-V victory" over a strait you can't sail through.

Democrats have a job here, and it isn't to wring their hands about norms. It's to say the plain thing, every day, in every district: this man started a war without asking you, sent eighteen of your neighbors home in flags, put your fuel at a record, and calls the coverage unfair.

Then ask the only question that matters. If that's the résumé, what exactly would failure look like?

If someone you know still thinks this war was won, forward them this issue.

Burn Notice: The war isn't over. The only thing Pete Hegseth ever finished was the victory speech.

— Michael

90 days free. BTP Insider subscribers get the Friday deep read, the monthly receipts digest, podcast Q&A priority, and the quarterly print bundle. The election room is open. Try it free for 90 days, no charge unless you decide to stay. Start your free trial →

Worth your time: We vet every brand and newsletter we recommend. Deals from brands we trust → · Semafor Flagship, the global stories that shape what happens here →